In general, consumers continue to perceive wild-caught fish as healthier and safer than fish farmed in aquaculture. However, the risks for human health posed by fish parasites that commonly infect wild fish remain largely unknown to the public. Among such parasites, nematode worms from family Anisakidae (hereafter termed as anisakids) are of particular concern due to their high prevalence in wild marine fish. The zoonotic potential of anisakids, along with their growing socio-economic impact on fisheries and seafood processing industries, are certainly worth investigating.
Here, we contrast anisakid infection risks in wild-caught versus farmed fish by synthesising ecological, epidemiological, and production-based evidence. Wild fish are integral components of complex trophic networks that sustain the life cycles of anisakids. Recent ecological shifts driven by climate change, host redistribution, enhanced fishing pressure, and the recovery of marine mammal populations, are contributing to an increased prevalence of parasites in wild fish stocks. Moreover, the higher prevalence of fish parasites on wild fish may also reflect changes in fishing and post-capture handling practices, together with major advances in parasite detection and diagnostic methodologies. In contrast, modern aquaculture operates under tightly controlled conditions that effectively disrupt parasite transmission, including the use of regulated feeds, biosecurity protocols, controlled rearing environments, and continuous health monitoring throughout the whole production cycle. As a result, anisakid infections are virtually absent from most intensive aquaculture systems, making farmed fish consistently safer with respect to any hazard driven by fish parasites to human health. This contrast highlights a key paradox: while aquaculture products are often perceived as being less safe for human consumption, the zoonotic risk they pose to public health is in fact substantially lower than that of wild fish.
Overall, the risks posed by the prevalence of fish parasites are paramount when addressing seafood quality and human health. Recognizing the benefits of aquaculture in parasite control is key for evidence-based risk communication and for reframing public and regulatory narratives surrounding the health value of farmed versus wild fish.
This study was performed under project “BLUE BIOECONOMY PACT” (Project Nº. C644915664-00000026), co-funded by the Next Generation EU European Fund, under the incentive line “Agendas for Business Innovation” within Component 5—Capitalization and Business Innovation of the Portuguese Recovery and Resilience Plan (RRP). This work is also funded by national funds through FCT – Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia I.P., under the project/grant UID/50017 (https://doi.org/10.54499/LA/P/0094/2020).