Efficient DNA extraction is a critical prerequisite for genetic studies in seaweeds. However, extract ing high- quality DNA from seaweeds is challenging due to their high content of secondary metabolites and other compounds that can inhibit downstream applications. Therefore, removing or inactivating these inhibitors is necessary for the success of PCR and other downstream applications. The most common DNA extraction method from plants is the CTAB (cetyltrimethyl ammonium bromide) protocol . Additionally, several commercial kits are available for plant DNA extraction. Due to the differences in seaweed composition compared to plants, these methods should be optimized to result in the highest possible quality and quantity of genomic DNA. Therefore, in this study, we optimized and compared the efficiency of four DNA extraction protocols, including CTAB, HotSHOT, DNAzol, and a commercial kit (DNeasy® Plant Pro Kit (Qiagen)) for DNA extraction from red seaweeds. Our comparison included DNA yield (μg/mg sample), concentration (ng/μL) , and purity (A260/280) . We also assessed the PCR and DNA sequencing successes using two primer sets (18S rRNA and rbcL ) on two red seaweed species (Hypnea sp. and Laurencia sp.).
The results indicated that the highest DNA concentrations were more common with the DNAzol protocol, followed by the CTAB protocol, then the HotSHOT, and finally the commercial kit. For the DNA purity, the best values were more common in the commercial kit samples, followed by the CTAB protocol. Most HotSHOT and DNAzol samples fell outside the 1.7-2.0 range, indicating that they need special instructions during PCR preparation. For the normalized DNA yield, the highest values were more common with the DNAzol protocol, followed by the HotSHOT protocol. In contrast, the lowest normalized DNA yield values were more common in both the CTAB and commercial kit protocols. Following special modifications and optimization , the highest PCR and DNA sequencing success was reported for the commercial kit, followed by the HotSHOT, then DNAzol, and finally the CTAB protocol. Overall, the results demonstrate that no single DNA extraction protocol is universally optimal for seaweed; DNAzol maximizes DNA yield, HotSHOT excels in PCR performance with minimal processing, and the commercial kit provides the most sequencing-ready DNA.