World Aquaculture Singapore 2026

June 2-5, 2026

Singapore

FROM FRAMEWORK TO FIELD: A PROTOCOL IDENTIFICATION PLATFORM FOR ASSESSING NATURE POSITIVE AQUACULTURE

Peter Benham*, Heidi Alleway, Tiffany Waters, Megan Considine, and Jonathan Mackay    

 

The Nature Conservancy                                                                
4245 North Fairfax Drive, Suite 100         

Arlington, Virginia 22203, USA            

peter.benham@tnc.org



The limited adoption of robust, replicable monitoring of ecosystem services on farms is a major barrier to the development of nature positive aquaculture. To address this, a collaborative initiative led by TNC published ‘A global monitoring, evaluation and learning framework for regenerative and restorative aquaculture: Helping nature thrive through aquaculture’. This framework provides farmers, government and supporting organizations with a consistent, evidence-based approach to measure the environmental and associated socioeconomic benefits that may or may not be occurring on their farms. However, while the framework establishes comprehensive guidance on practical, standardized monitoring approaches, a gap remains between the indicators and methods it outlines and their application and uptake in the field.

Through a series of surveys and informal interviews with a global network of 12 marine aquaculture farming companies, we identified a high interest in nature positive aquaculture but limited access and ability to implement actionable protocols. This presents several opportunities. First, farmers need a decision-support tool, or an “Protocol Identification Platform” (PIP) that—based on their location, ongoing monitoring, and MEL objectives—can support companies to identify which ecosystem services are relevant to measure, what tools and expertise is required to do so, and whether academic or professional partnerships are needed. Second, farmers need verified, farmer-friendly protocols that allow them or their partners to gather data in a trustworthy, scientific, and rigorous manner, the results of which they can communicate to their stakeholders.

To investigate these opportunities, we identified what pre-existing protocols exist that could be adopted to measure the indicators described in the MEL framework. We found that while there are some established monitoring methods (e.g. protocols for collection of video footage), most existing protocols require adaptation from their current context (restoration, research) to be usable in an aquaculture setting. In addition, many protocols require specialized academic or technical expertise to implement (e.g., species-level identification of epifauna), limiting their on-farm utility. We then reviewed and categorized existing protocols into tiers based on ease of adoption, considering both needed expertise and cost. Based on this tiered approach, we developed interactive decision trees that will lead to farm-specific tailored outputs from the PIP and built templates to provision usable protocols to farmers through this tool.

A ‘Protocol Identification Platform’ delivering verified farmer friendly protocols will enable farmers to adopt a validated pathway towards nature-positive farming models/labels, opening avenues for private and public support and investment, and allowing the industry to grow sustainably and favor nature positive practices.