Phosphorus is an essential micronutrient for fish growth and bone mineralisation. Fish can obtain phosphorus from both plant and animal ingredients, but the majority (60-90 %) of plant-derived phosphorus exists in an indigestible phytic acid form. Traditionally, fishmeal has served as a major dietary phosphorus source. However , increasing interest in sustainable feed formulations has encouraged the use of plant ingredients, making it important to understand appropriate phosphorus supplementation with different feed matrices. Our previous work revealed that environmental phosphorus levels did not affect growth or skeletal development in giant grouper, indicating that dietary rather than environmental phosphorus availability is the main factor of concern. Therefore, understanding how giant grouper utilise phosphorus from different ingredients is essential for formulating efficient and sustainable feeds. This study evaluates how various dietary phosphorus sources influence the phosphorus requirement for optimal growth and skeletal development in giant grouper.
An eight-week feeding trial was conducted using giant grouper (initial body weight: 32.8 ± 0.5 g) distributed into twelve 500-L fibreglass tanks in triplicate groups. A 2 × 2 factorial design was employed to evaluate the effects of ingredient source on the dietary phosphorus requirement. Four isonitrogenous and isolipidic diets were formulated using two different base feed formulations (animal-based and plant-based) at two total phosphorus levels (1.22% and 1.35%).
Fish fed animal-based diets had significantly higher weight gain, feed intake and bone hardness compared with those fed plant-based diets. In the animal-based diets, weight gain and bone hardness increased with higher dietary phosphorus levels. In contrast, no improvement in growth and bone hardness was observed with increasing phosphorus levels in plant-based diets. At the 1.35 % total dietary phosphorus levels, fish fed animal-based diets achieved 68.58% higher weight gain compared to the plant diets. Likewise, at the same phosphorus level (1.35 %) , breaking strength of bone was higher in fish fed the animal-based diet (49.3 ± 4.2 N) compared to the plant-based diet (27.5 ± 4.9 N). These results indicate that the dietary phosphorus response of the giant grouper is influenced by ingredient source, likely due to differences in total phosphorus intake, and phosphorus availability.