World Aquaculture Singapore 2026

June 2-5, 2026

Singapore

COMPARING THE PERFORMANCE OF FISHERIES AND AQUACULTURE WORLDWIDE

James L. Anderson*, Taryn Garlock and Frank Asche

Food and Resource Economics

University of Florida

Gainesville, FL 32611

USA

James.anderson@ufl.edu



Over the past decade we have been working to develop and apply Fisheries Performance Indicators (FPIs) and the new  Aquaculture Performance Indicators (APIs).   The FPI approach has now been applied to over 150 fisheries systems and the API approach has been applied to nearly 70 aquaculture sectors worldwide.  An essential feature of the FPI and API design is to develop metrics that are directly comparable between species, fisheries and aquaculture systems anywhere in the world .  Now that we have a large sample of global fisheries and aquaculture we can begin to explore different systems in terms of the environment, economics and social performance.  Despite the long-standing debate about the relative merits of fisheries verses aquaculture,  up until now  there has not been a  general tool nor the data availability to make objective comparisons.

This presentation will present some of the emerging results using FPI and API data to compare fisheries and aquaculture .  We focus on economic performance. Our preliminary conclusion supports the perspective that aquaculture sectors, on average, exhibit better performance than traditional fisheries in some dimensions .  Notably, less economic volatility, higher value-added products, less waste, more vertical integration and more competitive markets.