World Aquaculture Singapore 2026

June 2-5, 2026

Singapore

REFOCUSING AQUACULTURE POLICY ON FOOD SECURITY: CLARIFYING THE BOUNDARIES BETWEEN PRODUCTION-ORIENTED AQUACULTURE AND ECOSYSTEM CONSERVATION

Benter Anyango*, Hao Xu, Matthia Halwalrt, and Wenbo Zhang

 

College of Fisheries and Life Sciences

Shanghai Ocean University

Shanghai 201306, China

anyanobenter2017@gmail.com



Aquaculture now supplies more than half of the world’s aquatic food, making it essential to global food and nutrition security. However, challenges such as climate change, water scarcity, pollution, and biodiversity loss are increasing pressure to green the sector, leading to growing interest in ecological aquaculture. Using scientific publications from the Web of Science (WOS) (1980-2025) and funding information (2007-2027) from Horizon project data, the National Natural Science Foundation of China, and the U.S. National Science Foundation website, we analyzed trends in ecological aquaculture and general aquaculture research and funding. Ecological aquaculture practices include polyculture, marine ranching, integrated multitrophic aquaculture (IMTA), rice-fish (RF) systems, culture-based fisheries (CBF), dike-pond systems, aquaponics, aquatic plants (seaweed), and bivalve mollusks farming. Among these, polyculture, RF, and CBF have been the most successful and widely adopted due to their profitability, scalability, moderate technical demands, and lower labor intensiveness. However, IMTA and aquaponics remain largely experimental due to their complexity, labor-intensiveness, and low economic returns. Dike-pond systems have largely disappeared, while seaweed farming, despite its environmental benefits, faces challenges of limited expansion areas and markets. Additionally, regenerative, restoration, and conservation aquaculture, as well as environmental bioremediation practices, have been labeled "ecological aquaculture." The increasing global quest for sustainability in the aquaculture sector has led to rising research and investment in ecological aquaculture practices and concepts (Figure 1a), including systems that are not self-sustaining, unprofitable, complex, non-scalable, or labor-intensive, and fall outside the scope of FAO’s definition of aquaculture, as their primary objective is environmental improvement rather than food production for human consumption (Figure 1b). These systems misdirect scarce public funds away from scalable food production toward projects that function primarily as aquatic ecosystem management tools that are economically unsustainable and dependent on continuing public subsidies. To ensure aquaculture continues to strengthen food security, especially in developing and underdeveloped regions, policy frameworks should prioritize "food-first" systems while promoting environmentally smart, economically viable, and demonstrably productive ecological aquaculture models that can balance sustainability with food production.