Rice fish farming (RF), a centuries-old practice in Asia, represents a resource-efficient system that integrates rice farming with aquaculture, optimizing resources while addressing food insecurity and rural economic diversification. Despite its historical prevalence, benefits and potential adoption remain low, with many rice-producing nations failing to adopt RF. To determine factors related to success and failures of RF development, this study combines statistical analysis and case studies to examine the development status, trends, and socio-economic factors in major RF-producing countries. Our study shows that aquatic food produced in rice fields has increased from 0.97 to 4.72 million tons between 2000-2023, accounting for 5.00% of global aquaculture products, occupying 1.71% of global rice fields in 2023, driven by high-value crawfish in China and the US, and prawn and shrimp in Bangladesh. China dominates with 89.55% production and 86.54% area , this is followed by Bangladesh and Indonesia. RF is an extensive system, yet yield has intensified from 0.47 to 1.43 tons ha-1 over two decades. However, countries focusing on finfish in rice-fish system have stagnated or declined, as finfish are often low-value, have longer farming cycle than rice, and struggled to compete with intensive-pond aquaculture, while crustaceans are high value, almost synchronized farming cycle with rice, and are suitable for extensive systems. China’s success is due to government support, integration with other sectors, farm consolidation, consumers’ premium prices markets, and development of the whole value-chain. Unsupportive policies, water scarcity, low profitability, over-reliance on chemicals, and lack of knowledge reduce incentives for RF adoption. Scenario analysis reveals that converting 10% of the untapped global rice fields to RF could boost global aquatic food production by 28.34% (Table 1). However, realizing this potential requires government support, cross-sectoral integration, investment in farmers’ knowledge, resources, and institutional capacity.