The occurrence of infectious diseases poses a significant threat to the aquaculture industry worldwide. Therefore, characterization of potentially harmful pathogens is one of the most important strategies to control disease outbreaks. In the present study, we investigated for the first time the pathogenicity of two Vibrio species, Vibrio metschnikovii, a foodborne pathogen that causes fatalities in humans, and Vibrio areninigrae, a bacteria isolated from black sand in Korea, using a crustacean model, the signal crayfish Pacifastacus leniusculus. Mortality challenges indicated that injection of V. metschnikovii (108 CFU/crayfish) has a mortality percentage of 22% in crayfish. In contrast, injection of P. leniusculus with 108 or 107 CFU of V. areninigrae resulted in 100% mortality within one and two days post-injection, respectively. V. areninigrae was successfully re-isolated from hepatopancreas of infected crayfish and caused 100% mortality when reinjected into new healthy crayfish. As a consequence of this infection, histopathological analysis revealed nodule formation in crayfish hepatopancreas, heart, and gills, as well as sloughed cells inside hepatopancreatic tubules and atrophy. Moreover, extracellular crude products (ECP’s) were obtained from V. areninigrae in order to investigate putative virulence factors. In vivo challenges with ECP’s caused >90% mortalities within the first 24 h. In vitro challenges with ECP’s of hemocytes induced cytotoxicity of hemocytes within the first hour of exposure. These findings represent the first report that V. areninigrae is a highly pathogenic bacterium that can cause disease in crustaceans. On the contrary, V. metschnikovii could not represent a threat for freshwater crayfish.